Private School Elective Budget Planning: What a Course Actually Costs, and When You Have to Decide

TL;DR

• Elective budgeting breaks at small schools because the only unit most budgets can express is a teaching line — $47,000 to $70,000 a year — and no elective is worth a line until it's already full.
• The fix is to move electives off the staffing line and onto a per-seat line. A per-seat course is a variable cost you can size to actual enrollment: $149 per student per year, $129 at 25 seats, $109 at 50, and $99 for founding schools.
• Two decisions are live right now and they run on different clocks. The hole in this year's schedule is a discretionary in-year decision you can make in a week. Next year's catalog is a board decision that gets made between October and February — which means the pilot that justifies it has to be running by then.

---

It is late August. Your master schedule survived contact with actual students about ten days ago, and by now you know exactly which period is the problem. Somebody's teaching a study hall that was supposed to be a course. Or the elective you promised in the admissions packet is being covered by the person who already has five preps. Or you have eleven juniors who all want something you don't offer.

Every head of school I talk to in the last week of August knows this number precisely. What they usually don't have is a budget line to fix it with. The money conversation happened in March. The board approved the budget in May. And the thing you need now costs — what, exactly? Nobody's sure, which is why it doesn't get fixed until it becomes next year's problem, and then the year after that.

So let's do the arithmetic honestly, in the two forms it actually shows up: the in-year gap, and the next-year catalog.

Why is elective budgeting harder at a private school than a public one?

Public districts fund per pupil from state and local formulas, and a big high school amortizes an elective teacher across enough sections that the marginal cost per course looks small. Private schools have no such formula. Tuition is the revenue, and a teaching line is close to indivisible.

That indivisibility is the whole problem. A full-time teaching line at a small private or Christian school runs roughly $47,000 to $70,000 a year once you include benefits — and that's the smallest unit most school budgets know how to buy an elective in. So the head of school does the math backwards: how many students would need to take Forensic Science to justify a line? The honest answer at a school of 150 is usually "more than will ever sign up," and the course dies in the spreadsheet.

I've written about the per-seat cost of a private school teacher in more detail, but the summary is this: when your only purchasing unit is a whole human, every elective is an all-or-nothing bet on enrollment you can't forecast. The budget isn't tight. It's lumpy.

What does an elective actually cost per student?

Change the unit and the decision changes with it.

An online, credit-bearing elective supervised by a teacher you already employ prices per seat, not per hire. At Elective Genius that is:

Seats	Price per student per year
1–24	$149
25+	$129
50+	$109
Founding schools (first 10)	$99

Middle school Explorer seats are $49.

Run the comparison at a realistic size. Twelve students in one section, one supervising teacher who already has that period, at $149 a seat: $1,788 for the year. That is not a staffing decision. At most small schools that is a line item comparable to a field trip, a curriculum adoption for one subject, or a single conference registration — the kind of thing a head of school can approve out of discretionary or instructional-materials funds without reopening the budget.

Compare that to the same twelve students getting a course from a new hire. The teaching line doesn't get cheaper because only twelve signed up. And the per-seat line doesn't get more expensive if only six do — you buy six seats.

Two things follow, and they're the actual budget argument:

1. It converts a fixed cost into a variable one. You size the spend to real enrollment after students choose, not to a forecast made in March.
2. The downside is bounded and small. If the course doesn't take, you're out four figures, not a contract. That asymmetry is why this clears a board finance committee faster than a staffing request ever will.

The full pricing detail is public — I'd rather you check the number than take my word for it in a blog post.

Can I fund an elective mid-year, after the budget is approved?

Usually yes, and this is the part most heads of school talk themselves out of before they check.

An in-year elective add is almost never a budget amendment. At the dollar amounts above it typically falls inside one of four places money already exists:

• Instructional materials or curriculum — you are, functionally, buying curriculum plus the instruction.
• Discretionary or head's contingency — most small schools carry something here precisely for the thing nobody predicted in March.
• A restricted gift or designated fund looking for a defensible use. "We added a healthcare pathway for eleven students this year" is an easy thing for a donor to say yes to.
• The line you already didn't spend — the substitute budget, the unfilled position, the PD you cancelled.

The practical test is not "is there a budget line called Electives." It's "is this number small enough that I can decide it, and defensible enough that I'd be happy explaining it to the finance committee in October." At $1,788, for a period that currently has no teacher in it, that explanation writes itself.

The other half of the in-year question is time. A budget you could theoretically fund is worthless if the course can't start until January. This is why I keep pushing schools to think in weeks, not terms: setup is roster, assign courses, one supervising teacher, and students are in lessons. If you want the mechanics, I laid out the whole sequence in how to run an elective pilot at a small private school.

When does next year's elective budget actually get decided?

Here's the calendar that matters, and it's earlier than most people plan for.

Private school budgets are built by the head and business officer with the board finance committee, and the board of trustees approves the final budget before the fiscal year opens. Work backwards from that approval and the real sequence at most small schools looks like:

• October–November — enrollment projections and tuition modeling. Program requests start getting collected. This is when a new course either enters the conversation or doesn't.
• December–February — draft budget, finance committee review, staffing decisions. Course catalog and master schedule for next year get roughed in here, because you can't publish a catalog you haven't staffed.
• March–May — board approval, contracts issued, catalog published to families for course registration.

Which means the window for changing next year's elective offering is roughly now through February, and the useful part of it is the first half. By the time the catalog goes to families in the spring, the decision is a year old.

It also means something more useful: if you want an elective in next year's budget, the strongest thing you can bring to the finance committee in November is a course that is already running. Not a proposal. Eleven students, six weeks in, a supervising teacher who can describe what she actually does during that period, and a progress dashboard you can put on the screen. A pilot started in September is evidence by November. A pilot started in January is a request.

That's the honest reason to solve the in-year gap now rather than roll it forward. The in-year fix and the next-year budget case are the same project, done in the right order.

What should be in the budget request besides the seats?

Keep it short and make the non-obvious costs explicit, because a finance committee that finds a hidden cost later will discount everything else you said.

• Seats — students × per-seat price. The only recurring line.
• Supervision — usually $0 incremental if you assign a teacher who has that period. If you're buying a section of release time, say so, because that's the number that can actually move.
• Technology — a device and a browser. If your one-to-one program already covers the grade, this is zero.
• Credit and records — plan for how the course lands on a transcript before you start, not after. Carnegie Unit alignment, a standards crosswalk, and printable records are what an accreditation visitor asks for; I went through what reviewers actually look for in accreditation requirements for online elective credit.

What's not on the list is the thing that usually kills these proposals: a new hire. If the elective you want requires a teaching line, the budget conversation you're having is a staffing conversation, and it will be decided on very different grounds. Separating the two is most of the work — that's the argument in how private schools add electives without hiring teachers.

The decision in front of you this week

There's a period on your schedule right now with no real course in it. You know which one. It costs less to fix than most people assume, the money almost certainly exists somewhere you can reach, and fixing it in September is what gives you something to show the finance committee when next year's budget gets built in November.

The alternative is that the gap you can see today shows up in the exit interview in May.

---

Start Your Pilot

If you want to see the per-seat math against your own numbers — your grade levels, your enrollment, the period you're actually trying to fill — start a pilot or book a school demo. Founding school pricing is $99 per student for year one for the first ten schools, and there's no clock on it; when the ten are filled, they're filled.

We'll build the roster with you, assign courses, and get students into lessons. Then you'll have something real to put in front of your board.

---

About the author

Steve Smith is the founder of Elective Genius and spent 25 years in education before building it. He also runs Rosedale Christian Academy, where every middle- and high-school student uses the platform — which means every decision here gets tested on his own students first. Reach him at schools@electivegenius.com.